The Fiefdom of Ferrero and the Hazelnut Pesticide Paradox

Photo: iStock / Frank Nagel

By Maurizio Bongioanni and Rita Cantalino

One of Europe’s favourite sweet treats comes with a bitter environmental cost. The world’s hunger for hazelnuts is fed by a supply chain rooted in chemical dependence, ecological degradation and regulatory blind spots. In this investigation, Maurizio Bongioanni and Rita Cantalino trace the hazelnut trade from local landscapes to global markets, exploring the sweet spot between regulation, policy, trade and corporate responsibility.

ALBA, Italy – Welcome to the fiefdom of Ferrero, the multi-billion-euro empire behind household names such as Nutella, Kinder and Ferrero Rocher. It is here, in the foothills of Piedmont in 1946, that one of the world’s largest confectionery companies was born.

And the chocolate empire has left its mark on its home region, where the rolling hills are increasingly lined by Corylus avellana, the European hazel. 

Ferrero stresses that it neither owns nor directly farms the groves in Italy. Its role, a company representative explained, is that of “buyer and long-term technical partner”. Yet as demand from the hazelnut heavyweight grew, so did the production, growing from 8,000 hectares in 2001 to more than 23,000 in 2019, an increase of almost 190%, with 9,500 hectares added in 2010–2020 alone. 

Almost every nut grown on these branches is swallowed up by the confectionery industry, of which Ferrero is among the world’s largest buyers. 

This rapid expansion, however, has brought some unwelcome complications — most notably the brown marmorated stink bug (Halyomorpha halys), an invasive pest that damages the kernel inside the shell. First detected in Italy in 2012, it has since cost the industry millions, with an estimated €500 million of damage in 2019 alone. 

To combat it, growers often deploy a chemical carousel: deltamethrin, etofenprox, and lambda-cyhalothrin, a synthetic pyrethroid notorious for its toxicity to aquatic life and pollinators, yet permitted on hazelnut by the Piedmont Region’s guidelines for 2025–2026. Emergency-use approvals for pesticides such as acetamiprid often complete the chemical arsenal. 

Yet the long-term impact on the people who live alongside these orchards remains largely unstudied, despite the fact that work is underway in the neighboring vineyards of Langhe and Roero by state environmental agencies to map the impact of this chemical pressure. 

Enrico Rivella, a technician in the environmental assessment unit at Arpa Piemonte, the regional environmental protection agency, explained that Arpa does not carry out independent studies, but instead must be commissioned. Rivella noted that an earlier initiative to study hazelnut orchards stalled when regional funding was redirected toward developing disease-resistant plant varieties and addressing production crises like premature or excessive nut drop.

Passing the ball

For its part, Ferrero said it works hand in hand with “growers, technicians and the research world,” citing its Hazelnut Charter and dedicated technical manuals. 

On pesticides, it passes the ball back to the authorities: authorisations are the “responsibility of the national authorities within the European and Italian regulatory framework,” a representative from the company said. It cites, as proof of commitment, the Hazelnut Agronomy Program, developed with the European Institute of Innovation for Sustainability and the national association of agronomists.

Its answer skirted four of questions put to the confectionery giant: what Ferrero actually requires of its suppliers on permitted substances and residue limits; what share of its hazelnuts is organic and whether it has set any target; whether it would support a health study in the Langhe; and Lake Vico (more on this case below), which the company did not address at all.

Meanwhile, Ferrero’s defense of its position as a rule-taker, not a rule-maker, is put into question when set against its lobbying record. The company has been on the EU transparency register since 2011 and declared lobbying costs of between €400,000 and €500,000 for the year to August 2025, roughly double what it spent before 2020. It employs eight lobbyists, four of them accredited to the European Parliament, retains three Brussels consultancies, and states that it follows the corporate due diligence and deforestation files closely – the very instruments that would make it answerable for its supply chain. 

Commission records show eleven high-level meetings since 2014, including one on deforestation rules with two members of von der Leyen’s cabinet in May 2024, alongside Nestlé, and a meeting with Agriculture Commissioner Christophe Hansen in March 2025.

The d(r)ying lake

A few hundred miles south, in the volcanic hills of Lazio, lies Lake Vico.

Hazelnut farming here dates to antiquity, but the mid-twentieth century brought intensive monoculture. In 2018, under the umbrella of the Progetto Nocciola Italia, the Lazio region expanded cultivation past thirty thousand hectares, backed by long-term purchasing agreements with Ferrero, who agreed to purchase 75% of the local harvest. Coveted vineyards and olive groves were uprooted to make way for hazelnut trees.

It is what the Via Amerina bio-district, a group of organic farmers, calls an “anarchic multiplication” of hazelnut trees.

Many converted vineyards and olive groves into hazelnut groves, often started as organic during the first unproductive years to draw public funds. “Then, with the first harvests, they switch to conventional,” says Andrea Ferrante, coordinator of the bio-district.

Supporting thousands of hectares of trees is thirsty work, and hazelnut growers often turn to the nearby lake for irrigation. 

This has left the lake in a “comatose state,” according to Giuseppe Nascetti, professor at the Department of Ecological and Biological Sciences of the University of Tuscia. In a public statement, the ecologist called Lake Vico the “symbol of the ecological collapse,” pointing to the phosphorus and nitrogen — run-off from pesticides and fertilisers — that is feeding a toxic red algae bloom and rendering the lake undrinkable. 

The disaster led to the conviction of the Lazio Region by the Council of State, in 2024, for failing to comply with the Habitats Directive and for its inaction in the face of the pollution caused by intensive hazelnut growing. Meanwhile, other experts, such as the Doctors for the Environment association (ISDE), have warned against the degradation of the area, citing human health concerns.  

Beyond Europe’s borders

The pressure to feed the world’s hunger for hazelnuts extends far beyond Europe’s borders. Turkey is the world’s leading producer of the nut, supplying about 70% of the global harvest. 

A series of studies in 2012 in the provinces of Giresun and Kocaeli — the epicentre of Turkish hazelnut production, as documented by Turkish journalist Murat Cinar — showed, for the 2012 season, the active substances used on hazelnut groves. 

Among them were substances already banned in the EU, or about to be: azinphos-methyl, a neurotoxic organophosphate banned in Europe since 2006; methidathion and parathion-methyl, both classified by the World Health Organization among highly or extremely hazardous pesticides; methiocarb and the neonicotinoid thiacloprid. 

Under pressure to align with international trading partners, Ankara has since outlawed many of these substances on paper. Turkey now requires a pesticide to be registered in the EU or a G8 nation before it can be legally sold in the domestic market. On paper, the regulatory gap with Europe has narrowed.

Yet in the field, the distance between rule and practice remains. A Turkish news investigation from 2024 found that, between 2013 and 2022, overall pesticide use grew by about 40%, while formally banned molecules continue showing up in food. 

The Union’s rapid alert system, RASFF, has recently placed Turkey at the top of the countries flagged for banned-pesticide residues, with more than 400 notifications in both 2021 and 2022. In the first quarter of 2022, of 298 consignments of fruit and vegetables rejected for such residues, 60% came from Turkey. The alerts concern mainly citrus and peppers — not hazelnuts specifically — but they show a system in which a formal ban does not keep banned substances out of the fields.

A similar tension is visible in Chile, the world’s second-largest hazelnut producer and a leading global exporter. A 2018 Das Erste/Weltspiegel investigation documented the use of highly toxic substances, such as paraquat, on hazelnut plantations supplying AgriChile, Ferrero’s Chilean subsidiary. Paraquat has been banned in the EU since 2007, with other countries following suit. 

The concern is not confined to the plantations. Researchers at the Catholic University of Maule had previously detected pesticide residues in the urine of children from rural communities in the area, where schools sit adjacent to agricultural fields. Chile banned paraquat, chlorpyrifos and methomyl in 2022, but granted a ‘buffer phase’ until December 2024, criticised by the Latin American Network for Action on Pesticides and Their Alternatives (RAP-AL), which feared intensified use of remaining stocks during the extension.

Meanwhile, Ferrero’s hazelnut footprint in Chile has continued to grow. The company has opened a new shelling plant in Araucanía and upgraded facilities in Maule and Ñuble, while the country’s hazelnut area surpassed 46,000 hectares in 2024, and is projected to reach 64,000 hectares by 2030.

Different places, familiar pattern

Four geographies, thousands of hectares, and one increasingly familiar pattern: the expansion of hazelnut monocultures to meet global demand, followed by growing pressure on the ecosystems and communities around them.

In Italy the substances used are legal, but their impact remains unevaluated. Elsewhere in Lazio, where studies have been carried out, the findings were concerning enough to reach the courts. Meanwhile, further afield in Turkey and Chile, molecules Europe has banned for their toxicity have been documented in the fields that supply it.

The EU has tools to help close this gap. However, a flagship pesticide plan which would have set binding pesticide reduction targets, the Sustainable Use Regulation, was rejected by Parliament in late 2023 and withdrawn by the Commission in 2024. The corporate due diligence directive, which would have made large groups answer for impacts along their supply chains, was approved in 2024 and then gutted by the so-called ‘Omnibus’ simplification package.

As the saying goes, the devil is in the details. But for consumers, the distinction can be difficult to see. A hazelnut harvested in a field subject to European pesticide rules and one grown under a very different regulatory regime can end up in the same supply chain, the same factory and ultimately the same jar of spread. 

Disclaimer: The information and views set out in this report are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of the Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung European Union, ARC2020 and the organisations who contributed to the analysis. The Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung European Union and ARC2020 do not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this article. Neither the Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung European Union, ARC2020 nor any person acting on its behalf may be held responsible for the use which may be made of the information contained therein.

 

 
This article is produced in cooperation with the
Heinrich Böll Stiftung European Union.

 

 

More

Spilling Europe’s Dirty Secrets: Uncorking the Toxic Trade in Banned Pesticides

EU’s Simplification Saga Set to Continue Despite Legal Warnings

The EU’s PFAS Pesticide Blind Spot

Simplification Sandwich – What’s inside the Food and Feed Omnibus?

Op-Ed | Pesticide lobby use farmers’ protests as cover for slashing EU safety regulations 

Op-Ed | Europe Must End The Double Standards In Toxic Pesticides Exports

Op-ed – The Brave New World of Bayer & Co

Germany | To Reduce Pesticides, Start with Nutrient Management

Op-Ed – The Solution to Free Half of European Arable Land from Pesticides